I am joining another square swap and this one is Autumn rustic cabin. I found a great print which turned out to be a bit dark, so I bordered it with green to sort of bring out the colours. Now I have to decide on the other colours/ patterns. I had two pieces in my stash I thought would work. I made up two flying geese units but can't decide if they go well or not. Or if they do go OK, which one to use. This will end up being an 8 pointed star. Would you please tell me what you think? If you think I need to start over with new fabrics (except the cabin and green frame), then could you be specific? I will be making around 20 of these so would like not to purchase more than one other fabric. Oh, and excuse the mistake on the right goose -- I'm still learning how to make fabric go the way I want it to.
I like the one on left side. Susan
I like the one on the right, (as you are looking at the picture). It seems to me to pull the orange and yellow out of the cabin picture, and lets the green really stand out more.
It's a hard decision because both ways look nice. You put some good color combinations together.
I think your choices are gorgeous! The brown appears as wood grain that complements the cabin. The gold print is a perfect bright and your green evokes the woodsy feel. Well done!
I like the right side better also , great colors
I think either one would work, but I prefer the one on the left
I know you don't want to hear this, but I like both of them. I think it depends on what colors you would like to bring out of the cabin square. The fabrics you picked are perfect together. The colors you picked are just gorgeous together. I know you'll make the right choice. There is really not a wrong choice. Great job.
Georgetown CA I'd Rather Be Quilting
I like the one on the right better, I think it pulls the colors better. But, if you still can't decide I can give you a little trick my mother taught me. I couldn't decide on which dress to buy for my wedding over 50 years ago. I kept trying on the two choices. Out of patience, mom said "I've decided, take that one". I was disappointed and told her so. She said "Good, that's how you decide. Make a decision and if you're disappointed you know you've made the wrong one". Works for me. Well, maybe not always, but sometimes! LOL
In the beautiful Pacific Northwest!
i like them both, why not do half one way and half the other, it will add more interest to the quilt. alternate the light and dark stars
gini in north idaho
i like the one on the right. i also see a blue in the center block and hope you can use it somewhere in the quilt as well.
I am particular to framing it with the brown geese - then the gold and orange will pop - are you going to do flying geese on the top and bottom too - and then what color will you use for the squares in the corners - will you pull out the green again?
gini:i like them both, why not do half one way and half the other, it will add more interest to the quilt. alternate the light and dark stars
Belfrybat - Gini's thoughts are exactly what I was thinking. That way you don't have to make a decision. The quilt will have more motion and interest using both.
I prefer the one on the right. I think it pulls out the oranges and yellows in the center block better. I love these colors and this pattern. So beautiful! I love autumn.
Thank you for your replies -- looks like we are evenly divided. <grin> To clarify, this is a swap, so we each make identical squares, send to the hostess, and receive back a square from each participant. So I won't be making a whole quilt from just this one square. But if I did, making them half and half would certainly solve the issue. My concern (which you have all answered) was the russet leaf pattern might be too busy with the cabin square. But from your responses, apparently not.
I didn't want to waste fabric by making up 4 sets of flying geese besides deciding, but, yes, the flying geese will surround the center square making an 8 pointed star with the corners corresponding with whatever colour the center of the goose is. With that information, would you think having the russet leaf pattern touching the green (Right in my pic) make things too busy?